Doctor Who Complete Capaldi Ranking

The Capaldi era has come to a close as of Christmas which is of course incredibly sad. With Twice Upon a Time now included to the Capaldi collection let's see what that stands overall

1. Death in Heaven (Steven Moffat) == 88.67%

2. Listen (Steven Moffat)  = 88.00%

3. Dark Water (Steven Moffat) = 87.69%

4. World Enough and Time (Steven Moffat) = 85.71%

5. Deep Breath (Steven Moffat) = 82.86%

~ Into the Dalek (Phil Ford and Steven Moffat) = 82.86%

7. The Zygon Inversion (Peter Harness and Steven Moffat) = 82.73%

8. The Zygon Invasion (Perter Harness) = 82.50%

9. Mummy on the Oirent Express (Jamie Mathieson) = 81.67%

10. Extremis (Steven Moffat) = 80.77%

11. Hell Bent (Steven Moffat) = 80.63%

12. Before the Flood (Toby Whithouse) = 80.00%

~ Heaven Sent (Steven Moffat) = 80.00%

14. The Doctor Falls (Steven Moffat) = 79.33%

15. Under the Lake (Toby Whithouse) = 79.23%

16. Witch's Familiar (Steven Moffat) = 79.00%

17. Last Christmas (Steven Moffat) = 78.24%

18. The Pyramid at the End of the World (Peter Harness and Steven Moffat) = 78.00%

19. Twice Upon a Time (Steven Moffat) = 77.78%

20. The Magician's Apprentice (Steven Moffat) = 76.47%

21. Face the Raven (Sarah Dollard) = 76.16%

22. Flatline (Jamie Mathieson)  = 75.38%

~ In the Forest of the Night (Frank Controll Boyce) = 75.38%

~ The Woman who Lived (Catherine Treganna) = 75.38%

25. Empress of Mars (Mark Gattiss) = 75.33%

26. Knock Knock (Mike Barlett) = 74.29%

27. Robots of Sherwood (Mark Gattis) = 74.00%

~. The Pilot (Steven Moffat) = 74.00%

29. The Caretaker (Gareth Roberts and Steven Moffat) = 73.57%

30. Oxygen (Jamie Mathieson) = 73.07%

31. Thin Ice (Sarah Dollard)  = 73.00%

32. The Return of the Doctor Mysterio (Steven Moffat) = 72.00%

33. Smile (Frank Control Boyce)  = 71.66%

34. The Girl who Died (Jamie Mathieson and Steven Moffat)  = 70.83%

~ The Husbands of River Song (Steven Moffat) = 70.83%

36. Eaters of the Light (Rona Munro) = 72.30%

37. Time Heist (Stephen Thompson and Stephen Thompson) = 70.00%

~ The Lie of the Land (Toby Whithouse) = 70.00%

39. Sleep No More (Mark Gattis) = 68.46%

40. Kill the Moon (Peter Harness) = 67.49%

Series 8 Average: 78.98%

Series 9 Average: 77.14%

Series 10 Average: 75.51%

Complete Capaldi Story Ranking

1. Dark Water/Death in Heaven (Steven Moffat) = 88.18%
2. Listen (Steven Moffat) = 88.00%
3. Deep Breath (Steven Moffat) = 82.86%
~ Into the Dalek (Phil Ford and Steven Moffat) = 82.86%

5. World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls (Steven Moffat) = 82.72%
6. The Zygon Invasion/The Zygon Inversion (Peter Harness and Steven Moffat) = 82.61%
7. Mummy on the Orient Express (Jamie Mathieson) = 81.67%

8. Extremis (Steven Moffat) = 80.77%

9. Heaven Sent/Hell Bent (Steven Moffat)  = 80.32%
10. Under the Lake/Before the Flood (Toby Whithouse) = 79.62%
11. Last Christmas (Steven Moffat) = 78.24%

12. Pyramid at the End of the World (Steven Moffat and Peter Harness) = 78.00%

13. Twice Upon a Time (Steven Moffat) = 77.78%14. The Magician's Apprentice/The Witch's Familiar (Steven Moffat) = 77.74%

15. Face the Raven (Sarah Dollard) = 76.16%

16. Flatline (Jamie Mathieson) = 75.38%
~ Into the Forest of the Night (Frank Contrell Boyce) = 75.38%

~ The Woman who Lived (Catherine Treganna) = 75.38%

19. Empress of Mars (Mark Gattis) = 75.33%

20. Knock Knock (Mike Barlett) = 74.29%
21. Robots of Sherwood (Mark Gattis) = 74.00%

~ The Pilot (Steven Moffat) = 74.00%
23. The Caretaker (Gareth Roberts and Steven Moffat) = 73.57%

24. Oxygen (Jamie Mathieson) = 73.07%

25. Thin Ice (Sarah Dollard) = 73.00%

26. Eaters of the Light (Rona Munro) = 72.30%

27. Return of the Doctor Mysterio (Steven Moffat) = 72.00%

28. Smile (Frank Controll Boyce) = 71.66%

29. The Girl who Died (Jamie Mathieson and Steven Moffat) 70.83%

~The Husbands of River Song (Steven Moffat) = 70.83%
31. Time Heist (Stephen Thompson and Steven Moffat) = 70.00%

~ Lie of the Land (Toby Whithouse) = 70.00%

33. Sleep No More (Mark Gattis) = 68.46%
34. Kill the Moon (Peter Harniss) = 67.69%

Capaldi and Companion Scoring

For Stories Deep Breath - Hell Bent the companion present is Clara. For the Husbands of River Song the score is River then Nardole. From Return of the Doctor Mysterio it is Bill then Nardole. For Twice Upon a Time it is Bill than 1st Doctor than Archibald Lethbridge Stewart

Deep Breath: 10/8
Into the Dalek: 9/7
Robots of Sherwood: 10/8
Listen: 9/10
Time Heist: 8/7
The Caretaker: 9/8
Kill the Moon: 9/8
Mummy on the Orient Express: 8/7
Flatline: 9/8
Into the Forest of the Night: 9/8
Dark Water: 9/10
Death In Heaven: 10/9
Last Christmas: 8/9
The Magician's Apprentice: 8/7
The Witch's Familiar: 9/8
Under the Lake: 9/8
Before the Flood: 8/7
The Girl who Died: 8/7
The Woman who Lived: 8/-
The Zygon Invasion: 8/7
The Zygon Inversion: 9/7
Sleep No More: 8/8
Face the Raven: 10/10
Heaven Sent: 10/-
Hell Bent: 10/9
Husbands of River Song: 8/8/10
Return of the Doctor Mysterio: 9/-/8
The Pilot: 8/9/7
Smile: 8/8/-
Thin Ice: 9/8/-
Knock Knock: 8/7/-
Oxygen: 9/8/6
Extremis: 9/8/8
Pyramid at the End of the World: 8/8/7
The Lie of the Land: 8/7/7
Empress of Mars: 8/7/-
Eaters of the Light: 9/8/7
World Enough and Time: 10/9/7
The Doctor Falls: 10/9/8

Twice Upon a Time: 10/7/8

Peter Capaldi ends his era on an impressive 9 10's out of 40. Of the range 10-9 Peter manages to secure 21 out of 40.