Sunday, 11 October 2015

Doctor Who Reviews Series 9 Episode 4: Before the Flood

Before the Flood by Toby Whithouse

The second of a two part story by Toby Whithouse. It sees the return of the Tivollians as well as an Arctatieen Ship. It also mentions the "Minister of War" that has been mentioned a few times this series.

Doctor Rating:

Doctor Rating: 8/10

Companion Rating

Clara Osworld: 7/10

Enemy Rating

Ghosts: 7/10
Fisher King: 9/10

The Fisher King was an excellent villain but wasn't used to his best ability

Story Rating

Story: 9/10
Continuity: 8/10
Seriousness: 9/10
Scariness: 8/10
Humour: 7/10

Total: 41/50

Rest of Cast Performance

O'Donnel: 7/10
Bennet: 8/10
Lunn: 8/10
Cass: 9/10
Prentis: 9/10

Total: 41/50

Total: 112/140

Episode Rating so Far:

Last Christmas: 78.24%
The Magician's Apprentice: 76.47%
The Witches' Familiar: 79%
Under the Lake: 79.23%
Before the Flood: 80%

Story Rating so Far:

Last Christmas: 78.24%
The Magician's Apprentice/The Witches' Familiar: 77.74%
Under the Lake/Before the Flood: 79.62%

Interesting again as I preferred Under the Lake, however Before the Flood was still very good. 


No comments:

Post a Comment